Reviewer¹s Form

The Journal of Research For Educational Leaders

An electronic journal published by the Institute for School Leaders, College of Education, The University of Iowa

Home

System Requirements

Current Issue

Past Issues

Archived Issues

Guidelines for Authors

Format Design

Manuscript Form

Editorial Board

Reviewer Information Form

Other Links

Manuscript Review Form

On-line reviews of articles submitted to The Journal of Research for Educational Leaders will be conducted by reviewers selected from and by our editorial board. Submissions undergoing review will be placed on a protected web-site accessible only to approved reviewers. Reviews will be electronically submitted to the journal editors. Reviewers¹ comments will be compiled and forwarded to the author electronically.

Reviewer's Name:
Reviewer's E-mail Address:
Article Title:
1. Introduction
Article Introduction:	Accept as is Accept with minor revision Accept with major revision Unacceptable
Comments
2. Methods
A. Sample:	Accept as is Accept with minor revision Accept with major revision Unacceptable N/A
Comments
B. Instruments:	Accept as is Accept with minor revision Accept with major revision Unacceptable N/A
Comments
C. Procedures:	Accept as is Accept with minor revision Accept with major revision Unacceptable N/A
Comments
D. Design:	Accept as is Accept with minor revision Accept with major revision Unacceptable N/A
Comments
E. Statistics/Analysis:	Accept as is Accept with minor revision Accept with major revision Unacceptable N/A
Comments
3. Literature Review
A. Thorough and Appropriate:	Accept as is Accept with minor revision Accept with major revision Unacceptable N/A
Comments
B. Research reviewed and critiqued in article:	Accept as is Accept with minor revision Accept with major revision Unacceptable N/A
Comments
C. Organized and Focused:	Accept as is Accept with minor revision Accept with major revision Unacceptable N/A
Comments
4. Results/Discussion
A. Conclusion Clear and Logical:	Accept as is Accept with minor revision Accept with major revision Unacceptable
Comments
B. Practical Implications:	Accept as is Accept with minor revision Accept with major revision Unacceptable N/A
Comments
C. Future Research:	Accept as is Accept with minor revision Accept with major revision Unacceptable N/A
Comments
D. Other:	Accept as is Accept with minor revision Accept with major revision Unacceptable
Comments
5. Active Elements: Hyperlinks, graphics, slide presentation, audio, video elements
Hyperlinks:	Accept as is Accept with revision Unacceptable N/A
Graphics, charts, tables:	Accept as is Accept with revision Unacceptable N/A
Slide presentations:	Accept as is Accept with revision Unacceptable N/A
Audio:	Accept as is Accept with revision Unacceptable N/A
Video:	Accept as is Accept with revision Unacceptable N/A
Comments
6. Writing Style, Grammar, APA format
	Accept as is Accept with revision Unacceptable
Comments
7. Written Feedback to Authors

8. Recommendation for JREL
	Accept as is Accept with minor revision Accept with major revision - Rewrite, resubmit and review Reject - unsound Reject - - inappropriate for JREL; the following journals are suggested: